I loath everything about Raymond Kaskey’s 1985 hammered copper sculpture, bolted to Michael Graves‘ Portland Building.
The name sounds like boosters at the City Club thought it up on a boozy Friday afternoon. The first mention of the name in the paper of record is in 1986. Yes there are female trident-carrying goddess types in local decorative artwork, but these were previously referred to as “Columbia,” a general 19th Century patriotic icon, not Portlandia.
The location, perched on the third floor landing of a garish pomo hybrid government building, surrounded now by leafy trees, is both incongruous and hard to see. An unsubtle message from the City Forester who has selected thirty foot trees to block views of the sculpture from distance at every angle.
(The best place to see Portlandia is the observation area directly across the street in the Standard Insurance building, available 24/7 if you say hello to the security guard. Take the outdoor escalators up one floor.)
The pose of the artwork, at its on the Portland Building, is patronizing. The unsubtle message is, “Here, let the City and County bureaucracy give you a hand up from that hole you have dug yourself into.” Hunched, blank eyed, expressionless, it’s an arrogant provincial spoof of the Statue of Liberty. Perhaps the original proposal called for a welcoming gesture, but in artistic execution and surrounding context that proposed meaning is lost.
An example of how the banality bears fruit; when describing Portlandia, invariably the comment is about how large the artwork is, or how difficult it was to make, or transport. Never about the message, grace or beauty.
Regular readers know my affection for 19th Century narrative sculpture. Kaskey apes the Classical / heroic monument style using witless content, revealing the banality of his patrons. Tho the artwork is maintained on the chamber of commerce tour, visitors are puzzled. She’s large, not graceful; large, but hidden; large but why is it large? All that copper for what? What’s the what?
This is such a collegial, convivial town, true consideration of Portlandia has been an unobserved chuckle, added to a list which later included the Portland Tram and Wapato Jail, as attempts by disconnected politicians to satisfy business interests at the expense of fiscal prudence.
Jack Ohman sums Portlandia up in a recent editorial cartoon in the Oregonian, spoofing both the expense of the Portland Building and it’s poor interior design.
EXTRA – Portlandia Turns 20 in 2005, from RACC
April 28, 2008 at 9:58 pm
Well now thats not very nice.
I happen to find her intriguing.
I think it would be sweet if she were all the way on top of the building and able to be seen in the skyline…
I think she is pretty neat.
November 27, 2008 at 3:48 pm
I am very into sculpture, so I was interested in the second largest hammered copper classical sculpture…..
After considering it for a while I came to the same conclusion that you did.
A large copper sculpture to attract attention downtown = Great Idea.
Art controled by commity = Disaster.
Considering the time and money spent on such a project, it is really sad that it didn’t work out well.
The story reminds me of the “The Equestrian” in El Paso, Tx. That was a fantastic piece of art that was tainted by the Political Incorrectness and banished to an inferior location that makes your wonder how that can happen rather than wondering how could someone make such nice art.
The good new for the portland builders is that most people can’t evaluate art and if something is big and promoted as a destination, people will accept it and photograph the oddity on their cell phone and never understand or lament the squandered opportunity at greatness.
A SQUANDERED OPPORTUNITY AT GREATNESS
July 5, 2009 at 8:40 pm
I first saw Portlandia in 1989 and was awed at the sight of her. I have just returned from Portland and I seeked her out to get another look. I have to admit the building she’s gracing is dated (Art Deco I believe)and does nothing to compliment her but having said that, I still think SHE is beautiful. Being one to love art and sculpture I was also captivated by the Statue of Libery and I find Portlandia lovely as well. But I do agree with your remark about her being obscured by trees. She ought to be somewhere more exposed to have greater visual impact. And perhaps perched upon classical type architecture or something more fitting.